《新木马屠城记》是一部由约翰·肯特·哈里森执导,西耶娜·盖尔利 / 马修·马斯登 / 卢夫斯·塞维尔主演的一部剧情 / 动作 / 冒险类型的电影,文章吧小编精心整理的一些观众的观后感,希望对大家能有帮助。
《新木马屠城记》观后感(一):比brad Pitt版好了上万倍
没有丢掉原本故事的味儿,但又有了更丰富的情节。Helen是一个更重要的线索,正如标题所说。叫“木马屠城”却总觉得有点奇怪。
还是很感人的。每一个角色都塑造的很不错。甚至连Paris都没那么讨厌了。
阿伽门农和墨涅拉奥斯的形象我很喜欢。尤其后者。觉得他们已经不是高度抽象的英雄,而是有人性的真实存在。
阿伽门农一开始就意欲占有海伦。但海伦只是一个借口,他最渴望征服的是征服特洛伊。墨涅拉奥斯是个软绵绵优柔寡断的家伙。我很喜欢他和Hector决斗那段。不过电影在表现时间跨度的时候手法并不高明。并没明显感觉到有10年之久。Hector那么快就死了...弱化啊弱化!我绝对是有不满的...
整个故事很有神话的味道。服装,音乐,人物的口音与语气。觉得每个人都像极了我心目中的那个神话人物。无论是英雄们,还是女人们(尤其是Cassandra)。只是海伦一开始天真活泼的样子有点费解...
最后交代清楚阿伽门农死在了他老婆的手里,也是一个很不错的手法。觉得只有这样,一个歌颂爱情的故事才算是有了完整的结局。
百度百科是谁写的?谁说这是烂片来着?照我说,有Brad Pitt的那个版本才是烂片。别叫Troy,叫Achilles风流传算了,更商业更吸引...
《新木马屠城记》观后感(二):最完整的特洛伊战争始末
关于特洛伊战争拍摄过不少片子,谁都对古希腊神话史上因为一个美丽女人而发动的十年战争有所期待,然而似乎没有一个片子找到了众人心中的美女。在这个版本里,却展现了一个最帅的帕里斯王子,倒是小小安慰了一下。古希腊神话异常丰富,关于海伦的故事也有多个版本,这部影片的最大亮点就是将单个神话故事串成一条珍珠项链,有逻辑性地讲述战争始末,从内容上讲是最能帮助观众重建特洛伊传奇故事的版本。稍感冗长,但是瑕不掩瑜,对我们了解神话故事助一臂之力,画面也比较真实。对于前面评论说的色情,我特别不理解,应该是04版的才是色情与暴力吧
《新木马屠城记》观后感(三):TO 亲爱的海伦
总觉得女人的过分美丽真的是一种罪过——你可以如此的肆意,哭的最无辜,笑的最灿烂。更可以让无数的男人为你不惜一切,连生命都不要。真是不知道那些家伙在想些什么,仅仅为了你的美丽么?
仅仅,或者这个词用的很无耻,这样一个迷人的女子,连我都认真的爱她,何况那些男人?然而女孩对女孩的爱是完全不同的吧……没有看上她的脸,不会嫉妒。这种透明的爱和喜欢,是只想着迷乱的男人所无法感受的……
可是海伦啊,我又是这么恨你…………当女孩子已经只能靠着男子生存时,她就丧失了自己的本性了吧?即便你再灿烂的对着我笑,总还是少了什么的……当命运的指轮落到你丈夫里,当你母亲背转身不再要你时,你是否想过反抗呢?
特洛伊完了,帕里斯不在了,你被你丈夫拖回去的时候,我真的看到回身看我的你,静静的流泪了……
佳人倾城……
在希腊神话中,宙斯比孙悟空还会变身,一会儿变天鹅一会儿变水牛,上天入地探访美女,遗珠遍天下,因此他被封为“众神之父”倒也算实至名归,不过他也把希腊神话人物的血缘关系搞得一团糟。
宙斯的创造力点燃了历史上众多艺术家的灵感,其中出现频率最高的就是丽达与天鹅,连达芬奇都画过,丽达搂着天鹅脸上呈现蒙娜丽莎的神秘微笑。
叶芝认为历史旋体每两千年循环一次,循环由一位姑娘和一只禽类的结合引发,最近一次由圣母玛利亚和白鸽生下了耶稣,上一次是丽达和天鹅生下了海伦,世界大乱。
丽达是斯巴达国后,在国王丈夫和化成天鹅的宙斯的共同努力下,丽达产了两个天鹅蛋,每个蛋中有一对龙凤胎,其中两个儿子就是著名的双子座。
很复杂是吧?
(下面要剧透啦)
难怪导演砍掉了天鹅蛋、双子座变独子,并交待国王知道海伦不是自己亲生的很嫌恶她,丽达也羞愤而死。海伦只有一个兄弟。
阿伽门农来向海伦的姐姐克莱提斯纳斯求婚(神话中说姐姐先嫁了宙斯的某个儿子,阿伽门农杀死她的丈夫和孩子,强娶了她)他和弟弟梅尼勒斯同时觊觎着海伦,没等他们动作,海伦就被绑走了,作案的是两个老国王,他们通过掷筛子的方式决定海伦跟谁。有学者认为海伦与老国王生有一女,后来过继给自己的姐姐,就是阿伽门农杀了祭天的那个小女孩。导演没采纳这种说法,他认为老国王千里迢迢地抢个美人回来是要锻炼自己的定力,哈哈,原来老国王还是法海和甘地的祖师爷呢。剧中海伦对老国王施展青蛇对法海的那一套,老国王挺住了,随后和前来解救海伦的哥哥同归于尽。(神话中是老国王要还绑匪同伴的人情,帮人家抢女人被抓关到死,而双子座也是抢别人的双胞胎未婚妻未遂被杀)
于是海伦的爸爸国王就没了继承人,痛恨海伦之余,把她丢给一堆大小王,包括阿基琉斯,这里他变成一个肌肉发达嗓门震天的光头巨人,哪里是传说中穿女装可以乱真的美男子?我开始怀念《特洛伊》中的布拉德彼特,当时还觉得他的造型很糟,原来是没看到更糟的呀。大小王发誓不管谁娶了海伦,都要保护她的丈夫,今后对海伦只可远观不可亵玩。他们很没创意地再次掷筛子决定,结果海伦归梅尼勒斯,他因此继承王位当上了斯巴达国王。(神话中说海伦自己做主选的丈夫)
导演安排梅尼勒斯投桃报李,让海伦在婚前脱光光给几百个大小王细细瞧了一遍。嗯,女演员的身材比面孔漂亮多了,还是导演有洞察力呀。影片的名字Helen of Troy是一个成语,类似中文中的倾国倾城、红颜祸水、妲己亡商、西施沼吴之类的。其实拍著名美人的故事很难,演员太难找了,这部片子里的海伦比《特洛伊》里的略好,但也没到让人惊艳的程度,这一脱,不光大小王目瞪口呆,我也呆呆地想了半天,这么重要的情节看书的时候怎么会错过呢?
是不是以女演员的相貌引发一场10年大战不够号召力呢?反正导演很明智地让阿伽门农决定攻打特洛伊,抢夺丝绸香料商路和黄金。为此帕里斯才跑来媾和正好赶上了海伦的脱衣秀。四目相对,找到了梦中人。
海伦演出完毕才想起羞愧,跑去跳楼,被帕里斯接住……听到姐夫要杀帕里斯,美女救英雄……等帕里斯的船开走,她又跳海游泳追了过去……大军压境,她想起自己的责任要回去……战都打了10年了她才向预言家求教如何结束战争,这个海伦做事怎么总是慢半拍呢?
后来导演又取消了海伦在帕里斯死后的改嫁,反而安排阿伽门农强暴了海伦,而且大小王还帮着他拦着他弟弟……导演还真是喜欢让海伦脱衣服。于是乎罪大恶极的阿伽门农就被妻子杀了,海伦一百个不情愿地跟着丈夫回了家(神话中海伦还是施展了一些媚术才让他回心转意的)。
就这样,特洛伊被改写成了海伦和帕里斯之恋外带四五角关系。
《新木马屠城记》观后感(五):当看到阿伽门农被刺死的时候,我总算感觉到一丝的高兴了……
但我很高兴能够看到阿伽门农的死亡。阿伽门农,希腊联军统帅,在历史记载中,也是一个集无耻、卑鄙、下流和肮脏于一身的流氓。在英雄辈出和荣誉至上的年代中,这种害虫居然横行一时,实在是爱琴海湾的悲哀。
历史记载,阿伽门农最后死于妻子和妻子的情夫之手,死的好,死的妙。这样强奸犯,喜欢糟蹋女人的狗东西落得这样的下场,可谓是“人神共喜"。
历史记载,帕里斯是个窝囊废,然而海伦喜欢上这样的窝囊废真是她的悲哀,电影里的帕里斯竟然成了英雄。
还有值得一说的阿琉喀斯,很多人敬重他,可能是他们没有看过《荷马史诗》吧。阿琉喀斯,虽然能战,但是在人格上却存在着极其卑劣的一面。虽然说人无完人,但是他的卑劣也是别人不能比的。说他曾经解救阿波罗的侍女,但是更多学者认为他是向据为己有。他还屠杀了特洛伊所有人,包括老人孩子。
为什么阿伽门农和阿琉喀斯能够在一起,除了同样贪图金钱外,他们都是最强暴的强奸犯。
希腊联军应该以他们为耻。
看到电影中海伦被羞辱的镜头,我感觉到很压抑和莫名的心痛。英雄不是靠杀人杀出来的,而是凭借内心的高贵和体面的修养赢得人们的尊重。
我喜欢海伦,我从来都认为,祸国殃民不是美女的错。在那个黑暗的年代,这些美女其实是政治手腕下最可怜最可悲的弱女子。
1、维护王权,为了荣华富贵和快意人生,他们总乐意做王们的狗,用最大的能力太高王的地位,而将王犯的错误加到女人身上。这也如同恃强凌弱的道理。
2、他们都是意淫主义者,他们嫉妒身边没有如此的美女,他们憎恨自己为何没有这么轰轰烈烈的爱情,他们迷茫始终找不到值得自己守护的人。……
海伦如此,妲己亦是如此。
若真是可以换取海伦这样的女人,莫说一国,即便是我的所有连带生命,我也很乐意。
《新木马屠城记》观后感(六):Agamemnon's fierce eyes
A beauty, a hero, and a king, three person’s stories; beauty, courage, and desire, three different emotions. Their intersection is the movie "Helen of troy". Paris in the dark was suddenly coming out of the enemy draw knife stabbed several died on the spot ……Helen was raped by Agamemnon, who could not resist, In the end, back to the starting point - she still followed his husband, whom she did not love ...... the men, who personally killed his daughter for war ritual, Agamemnon, was eventually killed by his wife ...... the surprising plots to shook the people's nerves. If they had known these final results, will they go to still struggle for it? Still to pursue? Will they chooser the same choices.
Helen is the beauty, she represents the free of love. Helen is just a weak woman, even though she has a beautiful face. Every woman is eager to be a beauty, but the beauty of Helen brought her a series of disasters, “The beautiful woman suffered a harsh life”. Her beauty becomes the object of desires of many men: she is robbed by Theseus, then his brother robbed her back; her father hated her; the kings got together and decided her vest. Her body was her own, but she is not independence. All of these makes Helen flee. Perhaps it is unforgivable that Helen fled from Greece in the eyes of the Greeks. But as a woman, it is a pursuit of free love. For love, she blows everything. Helen, who is an active life, she knows what she wants, and pursuit of the goal of herself. She proved that women are not just an object of desire for men, she also has the ability to initiate the pursuit of love and happiness. From Helen I also thought of "Yingying biography" the girl Cui Yingying, and" Stone Story "Lin Daiyu."Stone Story "Lin seems to get rid of the tragic fate, the novel pointed to the Lin's identity at the beginning, she is the reincarnations of annatto, Lin struggled for independent personal love and freedom, she suffered extraordinary pains. Lin therefore shed the last drop of for true love.
In addition, from Helen's story, I saw the ancient Greeks’ questing for the beauty. As a modern man, I cannot understand, a decade of war, the ultimate goal of war is for a beauty, which no modern man can understand. Perhaps in the eyes of Greeks, The beauty is above anything, beauty is truth. The two sides compete for peerless beauty Helen, countless soldiers went dark for the beauty of sacrifice without regrets. Perhaps because of this, the ancient Greek create the elegant and refined, noble and lively, full of artistic expression full of beautiful statues.
aris is also a hero. He is different from the movie "Troy" that Paris no longer hid in the city, and did not meet the enemy, he is not the cowardly Paris. Although he was not the first warrior of Troy, but he does not intend to surrender to anyone, he fight for his own reputation. The pursuit of honor and dreams and goals of each ancient Greek hero. They process in the pursuit of honor, individuality, self-affirmation, to realize their own values, but also to indulge the desire to sacrifice moral, ethical. War is an important way to get the honor. the release of passion, you can win a lot of trophies, enhanced reputation, the subject of admiration. For example, Achilles would rather die, than want to lead his life comfortably at home.
Agamemnon symbolizes the desire, his desire to focus on three areas: the woman - Helen; for wealth, power; against honor. Agamemnon's desire to unite to meet the end of the movie, though, but with the life disappear, he could not really have his income. As a man, he was eager to Helen's beauty; as king, eager to wealth, power; as a great hero, the pursuit of honor. His desire, the more and more damage to others. To his desires, he snubbed his wife, killed her daughter, coerced brother, kill the tens of thousands of people. Sadly with the disappearance of his own lives, Agamemnon cannot really have his income. This is the tragedy of human destiny. Second, the pursuit of wealth and power. As a king, Agamemnon is thirst for power and greed for wealth, which coexists with the growing strength of his ambition. At that time the Greek states, the most powerful Mycenae, Agamemnon is the highest leader of the entire Greek region, he orders the pack, assembled troops. Achilles, Odysseus, Menelaus and so obey him. He wants absolute power, which makes him particularly arrogant men. He also wants to conquer the ocean side of the Trojan people, so that they surrender to him. In the film, his fierce eyes prove arrogant Agamemnon. Any of his decisions are irrefutable. He dreamed to conquer the world. In the film, Agamemnon is the object of many desires, he desire carrier interests, wealth, excuse powers and so on. After decades of war, he was loaded with booty, honor and go, very comfortable lying tub. Then Agamemnon reached the pinnacle of his life. He is successful, peak moment is also low moments, all of his life is together with his disappearance. People admire the ancient Greek heroes, we should also ponder war and humanity. Society needs proper desire, need good human, but definitely do not need
《新木马屠城记》观后感(七):谁的Troy
一部特洛伊,在100年间断断续续被搬上银幕,翻拍了六七回,一直拍到2004年。足见美人倾城,是多么唐璜而永恒的借口,让这碗以爱情佐料的旧饭永不冷场。
电影涉足史诗,多以以小见大的手法切入,反正不可能用两三个小时把所有的事情说圆,不如各表一枝,无限放大,其他的就让它化成语焉不详的尘烟。
《Troy》如此,《Helen of Troy》也是如此。
我发现把这两部电影交替着看,才能拼凑出一个大致完整的特洛依。主线一致,但各有侧重,互为补充。齐心合力丰满了这场希腊神话中最宏伟的战争史诗。
有足够豪华的明星阵容和宏大战争场面的《Troy》,众神和爱情统统靠边,大概是因为皮特够大牌。他扮演的阿喀琉斯头不大却比起任何一届都更有情有义,骁勇善战。就连他的死期也被人尽其才的延长到了木马屠城之后。
所以它的遗憾正如阿喀琉斯的脚跟,微小却是致命的——特洛伊——这么波澜壮阔的名字,不是一两个英雄的战争就能但待得起的。
将近三个小时的《Helen of Troy》,始终以一种平静得近乎残酷的叙事方式,还原了那场超越了战争本身的爱情。它是关于海伦的特洛伊,比十年的征战,这场爱情的浩劫更加残酷漫长,渗透并贯穿了她的一生。
要把“天下最美的女人”落实到电影里一个活生生的角色,委实众口难调。所以关于海伦的美貌,是难以言述的形态。既无关端庄,也不甚妖艳,却以人尽可夫的实用主义幸存到最后,也许才能满足所有人的胃口。
即便她是宙斯和丽达下的蛋,高贵血统和无与伦比的美貌也没能改变海伦的命运,她始终挣扎在女神们的自私和男人们的欲望之中,她的美貌在爱琴海迎风招展,爱情却在惊涛下撕成碎片。
在虚荣和贪婪面前,爱情不过是群雄挥舞的矛,诸神乱射的箭。
这大概也是我喜欢希腊神话的原因,在神灵面前,人类表现出来的抗争和无奈,背后都隐藏着无法逾越的巨大悲哀。
“What a man has to learn through suffering is not this or that particular thing, but the knowledge of the limitations of humanity, of the absoluteness of the barrier that separates him from the divine. It is ultimately a religious insight-that kind of insight which gave birth to Greek tragedy”
电影海报:
从电影海报就能看出这两部电影的侧重。左幅是03版的《Helen of Troy》,右幅是04版的《Troy》。
主题曲:
Remember——Josh Groban 2004年 希腊歌剧院的现场版
Remember, I will still be here,
As long as you hold me, in your memory
Remember, when your dreams have ended,
Time can be transcended,
Just remember me
I am the one star that keeps burning, so brightly,
It is the last light, to fade into the rising sun
I'm with you,
Whenever you tell,
My story,
For I am all I've done
Remember, I will still be here,
As long as you hold me, in your memory,
Remember me
I am that one voice, in the cold wind,
That whispers,
And if you listen, you'll hear me call across the sky
As long as,
I still can reach out, and touch you,
Then I will never die
Remember, I'll never leave you,
If you will only,
Remember me
Remember me...
Remember, I will still be here,
As long as you hold me,
In your memory
Remember,
When your dreams have ended,
Time can be transcended,
I live forever,
Remember me
Remember me,
Remember... me...
http://www.x5dj.com/UserForum/00100089/00228998.shtml
《新木马屠城记》观后感(八):美人啊,你把导演也弄瞢圈了吧
前半部分还凑合,貌似比Troy更写实,背景交待的更清晰,但是后半部分太扯淡了…
老国王千辛万苦偷来Helen,就为了锻炼自己的定力,照顾天仙长大成人啊!?就连Helen上美人计,都能够坐怀不乱啊!结论:还是演员不够漂亮啊。
米耐劳斯什么时候变的这么同情心,优柔寡断,非但没有趁机杀掉Paris,反而俩人还谈心来着?你是战士好么,你是斯巴达王啊
hector和achils旷世大战貌似进行了一整天,在这里俩人标枪定生死,achilis让了hector一回合,但是心慈手软的hector下不去手,结果一下就被定在了木桩上。hector啊,你毕生的使命就是,I defense my country啊,怎么到了打仗的时候,竟然妇人之仁,忘了当初你要杀死你弟弟的时候,是何等威武!
aris报仇心切,如有神助,一下就把 希腊第一勇士 撂倒了。虽说有太阳神暗中帮忙,但是有木有来得太突然。achilis十年手刃的特洛伊战士不计其数,怎么在这里一点没有体现,明明就是一届匹夫。。。。
最后,PS:这是古希腊神话啊,怎么能不露肉,不XXOO,不血腥暴力!
《新木马屠城记》观后感(九):A sad story of Helen
This movie tells us a story rather a piece of history. A story xabout love, desire and fate.
Instead of Trojan War, the movie focuses on the most beautiful woman in the world, Helen, and talks about her happiness, sadness, and her love story. This movie basics on the mythology of Trojan War, which remain for 10 years between Troy and Greek. Besides, the director and screenwriters add a lot of imagination of Trojan War into the movie, which makes this movie more attractive and dramatic than the history it is. The myth of Trojan War is about men’s power and strength. In “Helen of Troy”, the principle line is centring on Helen, and this original perspective of Trojan War brings us a new story and gives us another understanding of this myth. Compared with the fight scenes between two countries, the movie uses more parts to narrate the story of Helen. What’s more, it turns Trojan War from a ruthless war story into a moving love story.
At the beginning, infant Paris was predicted by his sister that his growth would bring the whole Trojan into death, and he was abandoned by his cruel father. The destiny was unfold before audience. Under the guidance of the goddess Aphrodite, Paris saw Helen from the gold apple, and Helen saw him in the water. Then they could not help but fell in love with each other. Their love were not accepted, because when Paris found Helen, she was wife of the king Sparta, Menelaus. Paris and Helen confront their love and impediments, however, this cause the conflict between Troy and Greek.
From this movie, we can see the tragedies of women directly. They did not have any rights to do what they like. They could not choose their loves, and women then were just used as a tool for men’s game of thrones. Such as Helen, she knew herself loved Paris when she saw him first time, but she still had to marry Menelaus. She could not make decision for herself. It is very ridiculous to blame Helen on causing the big war. Cassandra, who predicted the ending of Troy, always said that Helen would bring Troy into disaster. Who caused the war exactly? It were the aggressive men. Helen was just a brave woman who followed heart and chased her love. The emulative dominators would still fight against each other even if Helen did not escape with Paris. Helen was used as a tool or a reason for men’s conquer. Therefore, it was not fair for Helen to undertake the responsibility of Trojan War.
There is another question, what is the fate? In Cassandra’s eyes, Paris made Troy burnt, and Helen’s arrival brought Troy unfortunate is the fate. Nevertheless, in my opinion, the fate is that Helen and Paris hit it off right from the start. The fate in this story is love rather than the war.
In addition, we can see the greedy and cruel men in that period especially in Greek. Agamamnon and Achilles are described as such hateful men. By contrast, Paris and Menelaus are more kind and lofty. In fact, before I watched “Helen of Troy”, I was more supporting Greek side, because it was Troy who had prior fault, and it was Paris who robbed Menelaus’ wife. However, the charactors in this movie were depicted very vivid, it successfully changed Paris into a brave, kind, and upright boy, and also, Menelaus became a humane person.
The background music of this movie is beautiful and graceful, and it sounds like telling a sad story. Especially after Paris was died and Troy was occupied by the Greeks, Paris appeared infront of Helen, which was just the hallucination of Helen. The frames combined with the music makes audiece feel regretful for Helen. Trojan War was a disaster, not only for Troy, but also for Helen.
As the movie tells us at last, “War is waged by nations, but it is the human beings that pay the price.” The poor citizens suffered the severe pain, as well as Helen, the poor woman who lost her love, the love which she ever called it “hope”.
《新木马屠城记》观后感(十):苦苦的挣扎换来了什么?
有预见未来的能力似乎未必是好事,片子里帕里斯的姐姐,因为企图用她预见的悲剧说服父亲,试图改变未来,却换来被自己父亲关进天牢的凄惨情状……
而绝大多数的人无法预知,因为无法预知而总盼望着更美好、更幸福,而不肯珍惜身边拥有的……
海伦从那个抓阄得来的丈夫身边逃开,为了追寻她的真爱,企图挣扎着得到幸福……
于是,海伦和帕里斯相携相守的愿望给战争制造了借口,十年的煎熬和血腥的浩劫由此开始……
十年,她和他朝夕相处、甜蜜温馨的十年,却是特洛伊城处于敌人窥视中惶惶度日、城外爱琴海士兵背井离乡、远洋争战备受折磨的十年……
最后屠城时,士兵们近乎病态的虐待被俘的弱民,特洛伊城果然如最初的预言一般,成为一片废墟……
而,这战争最初的导火者又是怎样的结局呢?
帕里斯在暗夜里冷不丁冒出来的敌人数刀抽刺当场惨死……
海伦被敌人强暴,没有一丁反抗的余地,最后的最后,竟然回到了起点——依然跟随着她不爱的丈夫……
亲手杀死自己女儿祭神发动战争的,最终却被自己的妻子杀死……
还有斯巴达王为了一份迷恋,变成兄弟发动战争的棋子,经历十年的煎熬和等待,换来的是,亲眼看着兄弟强暴自己心爱的女人……
我在想,如果人们早知道最终的结果,他们还会去挣扎么?
如果海伦知道她的追寻会让自己心爱的人惨死,而最后依然只能跟随自己原本的丈夫,她难道不会选择把真爱和希望珍藏于心,给所有无辜的人一份安宁与和平么?